Yokemate of Keyboards
Posts: 2720 from 2003/2/24
Quote:
Andreas_Wolf wrote:
> As far as I know [...], they only support in the works is limited to Apple AGP cards.
> [...] they have focused on cards that are supported by the machines we are using
Okay, I think this would mean Radeon X800/X850 with R420/R481 GPU then.
> even if PCIe G5 support were to be announced (and I am pretty sure that is not imminent)
"Support for more G5 models" could mean just this. Or it could mean even older PowerMac G5 models than are supported now (is this likely?). It could also mean iMac G5. And considering that both support for more recent graphics cards and support for more G5 models are supposed to come in MorphOS 3.6, which is 3 releases away, it doesn't have to be imminent.
> the focus on Apple supported cards means they won't be that much more recent.
Yes, we now that those don't go above the Radeon X1900 (R580).
Yes, I agree. Under all circumstances I think we can assume that they will stick to Radeon's, meaning that all Nvidia cards are out of the picture.
Then if we look at AGP only (AGP 8x to be more precisely) we have the Radeon R400 architecture from which the two cards X800XT and X850XT came as OEM Apple G5 cards AFAIK. Performance wise they should be better than GeForce 6800 Ultra but below GeForce 7800GS, and could work as a good replacement for the R300 family of cards found as standard in "our" current line of supported PowerMac7,3 G5 computers. This is probably the best there is for Radeon/AGP 8x/Mac. Note that the cards can also be modified to work with AGP 4x/PowerMac G4 by
disabling the pins 3 & 11 of the card (if you are buying second hand, it might be good ask questions about this before buying). It seems to be available in good supply.
Well, this has covered "more recent graphic cards" for the *currently supported* G5 models, but the roadmap stipulated "support for more G5 models". So what can that mean when it comes to "more recent graphic cards"?
Well, we have the iMac G5's of course. The first series of iMac G5, the "PowerMac8,1", used GeForce from Nvidia, which goes away. The second series, the "PowerMac8,2" used Radeon 9600, which hardly qualify as "Support for more recent graphic cards". The last iMac G5 series before they went "Core Duo", is the "PowerMac12,1", which used a Radeon X600 Pro, which is a family of chips that basically is the R300, but with PCI-Express instead of AGP. This doesn't qualify as "Support for more recent graphic cards" either!
They could also introduce support for the
older line of PowerMac G5's, the "PowerMac7,2" series. But those have also an AGP 8x bus, so the same as above is applied to them, the R400 family's X800XT/X850XT will be the "most recent" graphic cards possible, right?
They could also introduce support for the
newer line of PowerMac G5's, the last ones ever built, the "PowerMac11,2" with PowerPC 970MP CPU's and PCI-Express. Unfortunately, all these came with GeForce 6600 as standard, so a GFX card switch is mandatory. Then the best G5 compatible card I can find, is the ATI Radeon X1900 Mac G5 Edition. It should perform slightly better than a GeForce 7800GT. It seems to be available in good supply.
To sum it up, can it mean anything else than the R400 family's X800XT/X850XT for AGP 8x, or X1900 Mac G5 Edition for PCI-Express?
MorphOS is Amiga
done right! MorphOS NG will be AROS
done right!