im not narrowminded but my experience with scrolling pc dos games at that time is that they're crap:) almost all of them looked better coz the 256 vga palette, but on amiga it feels a lot smoother (slamtilt, anyone?:).
and i played a lot of games on both platofrms back then. in fact these kind of games prooved that the amiga is superior than pc, and i could show them to my pc-owner buddies - ok, i was 1x yrz old then:)
maybe one example came in mind wich can proove your point: xenon2. i played it on a 386pc first then on a500 and i was wonder why is it so slow?:)
DEAD pegII/G4@1000.1gb ram.radeon 9200pro
240 gigz hd.nec dvdrw.MorphOS 2.4 DEAD