I think the reason that the AOS4 community is more active, besides pure love, is because it demands such a huge investment to get it that people get more attached to it. When you pay 1500€ for something, you want your moneys worth of it. When you pay 30€ for a Mac Mini to test a free version of MorphOS there is not much loss if you put it in the closet after 5 minutes.

As for the situation, heated discussions aside, I think it's good we have 3 NG OS's. It's proof that people work their ass off in their respective camps to keep the Amiga alive for the future. I don't have to like or respect everything that is done and decided, but I do respect the underlying passion that makes people do it. Even when the turnout is questionable.